Social Sciences
2 years ago

Dissenting Ingroup Members Elicit More Negativity Than Outgroup Critics

When Group Members Dissent: A Direct Comparison of the Black Sheep and Intergroup Sensitivity Effects
Anna Reiman, Tina Killoran

Paper Summary

Related papers

Theme background image
Social Sciences
2 years ago

Dissenting Ingroup Members Elicit More Negativity Than Outgroup Critics

Intergroup Relations
Opinion Dynamics
Professional Dynamics
1 view
Theme background image
Social Sciences
5 years ago

Violent Conflicts Breed Distrust, Divide Economies Along Group Lines

Culture Influence
Economic Behavior
Intergroup Relations
2 views
Theme background image
Social Sciences
8 years ago

Embracing Group Norms Leads to Social Influence and Positive Identity

Social Norms

People react differently to criticism from within their group compared to criticism from outsiders. In a study about U.S. political parties, when someone criticizes their own party, they are seen more negatively by their group members (black sheep effect). However, criticism from an outsider is viewed even more negatively (intergroup sensitivity effect). This shows that while criticizing your own group can make you a "black sheep," it also comes with some understanding.