Philosophers Discover Impossible Rules, Shaking Foundations of Logic
The article discusses different types of rules: necessary rules that can't be broken and normative rules that should be followed. The author argues that these two types of rules are separate and can't overlap. However, Brandom's inferential rules try to be both necessary and normative. This creates a problem because rules that must be followed can't always be rules that should be followed. The concept of normative necessity in inferential rules poses a challenge in philosophy.